The Gospel Versus Nostalgia

This summer I had the privilege of travelling to Eastern Europe to attend my brother’s wedding. His wife, Annette, is a native of Krakow, Poland. After the wedding, I continued on to Slovakia to visit missionaries we support near Bratislavia. Jason and Adele Rice and their three young boys have just got to the field and are busy learning the language and culture of Slovakia.

There is something about the mindset of an overseas missionary that would be good for us American Christians to learn. It struck me that missionaries don’t go into a country and try to change the entire governmental structure all at once. That’s not even on their agenda.Over time, their work may lead to positive changes in the country’s culture (See Hudson Taylor, William Carey, Adoniram Judson). But missionaries don’t complain about a country’s culture, but seek to minister in it as it is.

I wonder if American Christians need to start thinking of themselves as missionaries in their own cultures. We’ve had the privilege of growing up in a country that at least acknowledged Christianity even if it was in a national, generalist, fuzzy form. In other words, in America, we generally have gotten back pats and attaboy’s for being Christians. We are accustomed to that so much that when the greeter at Walmart doesn’t automatically belt out a rendition of “Silent Night” after scanning our items, we throw up our hands in horror at the new “War on Christmas.” Most of the Right’s “War on Christmas” meme is hyperbole. But it acknowledges a reality we must get used to if we are going to take the Great Commission seriously: we are missionaries in a culture that is less supportive of biblical Christianity.

We can respond to this reality in two ways: a) We can operate out of fear and continue to try to “take our country back” or b) we can recognize what the Bible recognizes: followers of Christ will always be a misunderstood minority. We’re missionaries. And missionaries don’t complain about the culture they are called to serve. They simple learn the culture and get busy faithfully sharing the good news of the gospel.

What kills our witness is nostalgia. Nostalgia, I’m afraid, is against the gospel. Nostalgia says that there was once a time, maybe its the 1950’s, where we got everything right and America was golden. Nostalgia says, “This is the worst time ever. Sin has never been more rampant.” I can’t tell you how many books I read that appeal to this. There are statistics about how many marriages failed in the early 20th century compared to now, as if adultery and sexual sin are a new invention. But then I open my Bible and find that the same sins that plague us in the 21st century plagued the very first generation of humanity. There was brother-on-brother murder in the second generation. And the pages of Genesis, pre-Flood, read like a transcript of the Jerry Springer show. And consider the book of Judges. Consider the sins the book of Romans describes. Consider Paul’s rebuke of the Corinthian church.

The point is this: sin has always been rampant among humans. There was never a golden age where life was all beautiful. Why do we think this way? Personally I think there is a part of us that longs for utopia–and tries in vain to create it here on earth. Perhaps its our sorrow at being kicked out of Eden and our longing for the eternal home of Heaven.

Here’s how the gospel differs from nostalgia. The gospel instructs us to look back, but not to the Eden we’re missing or to some mythical golden era, but to the cross, where sin and death were defeated, where the enemy of our souls was crushed once and for all. The gospel is always pointing us, not backward, but forward. Hebrews reminds us that we are a people who are not looking backward, but forward to a “city whose builder and maker is God (Hebrews 11:10).”

We can learn from other eras, we should drink deeply from history, we should imbibe the best of the Reformers, the Puritans, the ancient church fathers. But we must always seek to bring the gospel to today’s world, to live missionally in the culture that is not lament a culture gone by.

Because real missionaries don’t complain about the country that isn’t, but serve the country that is.

Daniel Darling is the Vice President for Communications at the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention. He previously served five years as Senior Pastor of Gages Lake Bible Church. He is a contributor to Leadership Journal, Homelife,, Stand Firm,” and a variety of other evangelical publications. He has written several books, including his latest, Activist Faith.

Please note: I reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive or off-topic.

9 thoughts on “The Gospel Versus Nostalgia

  1. Dan, one difference, of course, is that we are citizens of this country and have legitimate reasons for wanting to shape its culture. That said, it may be true that we are too invested in making the culture Christian rather than in making Christians within the culture. Good post, and very right on about the nostalgia element.

    • Larry,

      Good point. We do seek to shape the culture and community–this is Jeremiah\’s instruction to the exiles in Babylon and, I believe, part of the way we live out the Kingdom, so yes I agree. It\’s also how we love our neighbor by seeking to build a community that is best.

      I guess what Christians have to do now, though, is to stop pining for a mythical day when all was right and get to work now, today, in shaping the culture as it is. This is why I think the talk of a Christian nation is really destructive to our faith in many ways, as if we cannot live in a nation that doesn\’t automatically affirm us.

      Good point–really good point.

  2. Wow, great stuff. We need more people calling the church back to the biblical gospel and away from the idolatrous goal of 'restoring America'. As you say, restoring it to what? A time when the veneer of Christianity was a bit thicker than it is now but people's hearts were just as wicked? Personally, I'd prefer the distinction between the church and the culture to be more clear so we know where our mission field is.

  3. I agree. I am convinced it is time to let go of the past and accept that we are Christians in a pagan culture and build from there. Good post.

  4. Thanks for reminding us about what counts, Daniel. I would like to suggest that one of the reasons people care about the "sin has never been more rampant than today" attitude is because of prophetic chapters such as 2 Timothy 3 which talk about Godlessness in the last days. It is however ironic that such passages are usually written to make us long for the return of Christ, not to inspire us to "take back" our society. I am persuaded that this disconnect is one of the numerous distractions by the evil one, to keep our attention diverted from what matters most, sharing the unadulterated Gospel of Jesus Christ crucified.

    • Cornell,

      Good point. There are those prophetic passages that warn us of symptoms of the last days, though technically the last days are the entire church age. Great comments.

Comments are closed.